Vantage FX vs CityIndex Broker Comparison

Are you trying to figure out which is a better broker, Vantage FX or CityIndex? After rigorously testing both brokers and putting each through our accurate and extensive reviewing process, we have concluded that Vantage FX is the better of the two. Vantage FX offers 300+ instruments, licenses from FCA, ASIC, CIMA, and fair trading fees.

In the tables below, you can compare the features of Vantage FX and CityIndex side by side, to work out which suits your trading needs best. You can also carry on reading to find out why our experts ranked Vantage FX higher than CityIndex.

Rating
95.3/100
94.5/100
Min. Deposit
200$
150$
Regulated By
FCAFCA
ASICASIC
CIMACIMA
FCAFCA
ASICASIC
Bonus
50 USD No Deposit Bonus
No Information
Min. Spread
1.4
0.5
Max. Leverage
1:500
1:500
Currency Pairs
40
84
Trading Instruments
300+
4,500+
Trading Platforms
MT4, MT5, WebTrader, Private
MT4, WebTrader, Private
Deposit Methods
Bank transfer, Visa, MasterCard, Skrill, Neteller, FasaPay and more
Bank TransferBank transfer, Visa, MasterCard, PayID, PayPal and more
Type of Brokers
STP/ECN
Market Maker
Customer Support
24/5
24/5
Language Support
5
1
Established
2009
1983
Used By
650,000 Traders
100,000+ Traders

Does Vantage FX or CityIndex have lower trading costs and fees?

To compare the costs of trading at different brokers, our experts analyze both trading-specific fees, such as spreads, and non-trading fees, such as inactivity charges and payment costs.

To give an overall view of how cheap or expensive Vantage FX and CityIndex are, we first considered the common fees on Standard Accounts. At Vantage FX the average spread for the EUR/USD currency pair is 1.4 pips, whilst at CityIndex the spread is 0.5.

This shows that CityIndex is the better option for low-cost forex trading.

When it comes to non-trading fees, Vantage FX charges for . CityIndex charges for inactivity. With this in mind, Vantage FX has lower non-trading fees.

When our experts analyzed the specific costs of both brokers, we found that Vantage FX is the better option.

Trading Fees*

*Based on Standard account type.

Non-Trading Fees

Which broker is safer, Vantage FX or CityIndex?

In order to decide how safe our top-rated brokers are, our experts look at a number of factors. This includes what licenses the broker holds and how reputable those licenses are. We also consider the history of the broker, as a long-standing broker is often more reliable and trustworthy than a newer one.

Vantage FX is regulated by FCA, ASIC, CIMA and offers client protection. CityIndex is regulated by FCA, ASIC and offers client protection.

Considering these two factors, and the general reputation and history of both brokers, we believe that CityIndex is the safer broker.

Broker summary

How many trading instruments are available at Vantage FX and CityIndex?

Vantage FX provides traders with 300+ instruments. This includes 40 currency pairs, 0 cryptocurrencies, and 100 stocks and shares. With Vantage FX, you can also trade CFDs.

In comparison, CityIndex boasts 4,500+ tradable instruments. CityIndex offers 84 currency pairs, 5 cryptocurrencies, and 4,500 stocks and shares. CityIndex also allows CFD trading.

As both brokers offer the same total number of instruments, both are great choice if you are wishing to diversify your trading portfolio.

Markets and Products

Which broker offers the best trading platform, Vantage FX or CityIndex?

When our experts review a broker, they open their own accounts and place trades via the broker’s trading platform. This allows them to fully evaluate the quality of the platform, how easy it is to use and what features it offers.

Vantage FX provides you with the ability to trade via 4 trading platforms, and CityIndex has 3 trading platforms. Both brokers also offer research and trading tools, however Vantage FX has more.

Overall, our experts agree that Vantage FX boasts the better trading platform offering.

Research Tools

Which is better for beginners, Vantage FX or CityIndex?

To decide how well-suited a broker is for beginner traders, our experts look at what educational materials are available, how accessible the minimum deposit limits are, the range of account types and whether or not you can practice trading with a demo account first.

Considering this, our reviews show that CityIndex is the better broker for beginner traders as it offers a larger range of educational tools and materials. CityIndex also has a minimum deposit of $.

Educational Features

Which broker is better overall?

Overall, our tested reviewing methodology proves that Vantage FX is the better broker in a range of key areas. You can learn more by reading our Vantage FX and CityIndex reviews.

Vantage FX vs CityIndex
Vantage FX
95.3
Points
CityIndex
94.5
Points
Overall
1 points
Vantage FX
96
Points
CityIndex
92
Points
Commissions & Fees
4 points
Vantage FX
97
Points
CityIndex
98
Points
Licensing & Safety
1 points
Vantage FX
99
Points
CityIndex
97
Points
Trading Platforms & Tools
2 points
Vantage FX
98
Points
CityIndex
95
Points
Payments
3 points
Vantage FX
94
Points
CityIndex
94
Points
Customer Service
Vantage FX
88
Points
CityIndex
91
Points
Educational
3 points
Open Account in Vantage FX