Explaining the Difference Between Engulfing and Piercing

After morning and evening stars, another important reversal patterns under the Japanese Candlestick Techniques are the engulfing and piercing ones. They seem to be similar to many people, but they are quite different and their interpretation should be different as well. The interpretation refers to the price action to follow such patterns. The engulfing pattern is far more powerful than the piercing one, in terms of the new trend that is about to start. While hammers and doji candles are one candle patterns, the engulfing and piercing patterns are two candles patterns and represent a major reversal signal with opposite color for the bodies of the candles composing this pattern.

Types of Engulfing and Piercing Patterns

Before discussing the different types of engulfing and piercing patterns, it is important to define what they are. In an engulfing pattern, the second candle wraps around or engulfs the prior candle’s body. This is showing buying pressure if the pattern is forming after a bearish trend, or selling pressure if it is forming after a bullish one. On the other hand, in the piercing pattern, the second candle fails to completely retrace the previous one. This is the main reason why the piercing pattern is less powerful than the engulfing one.


Broker Min Deposit Regulation Bonus Read More Visit Site
XM $5 CySec 100% Read Review Visit Broker
XTrade $100 CySEC 60% Read Review Visit Broker
HYCM $50 FSA $5000 Read Review Visit Broker

Bullish and Bearish Engulfing

The engulfing pattern forms when the following conditions are met:
– The market is in a clear uptrend or downtrend, no matter if the trend is short-term or medium-term one;
– There are two candles that move in opposite directions, with the second candle totally retracing and engulfing the prior candle’s body;
– The second candle must be different than the previous one. This means, if the first candle in the pattern is a bearish one, the second one needs to be a bullish one and the other way around.

Bullish Engulfing

Explaining the Difference Between Engulfing and Piercing1Having said that, a bullish engulfing pattern is forming at the end of a bearish trend, with the first candle being a candle that goes in the same direction as the previous trend, a bearish one, and the second candle should be a big green one that totally engulfs the previous candle. There is a small difference between what the definition of an engulfing pattern shows and how the pattern is looking like when analyzing the Forex market. The reason for this comes from the fact that under the original definition, the second candle in the pattern should gap a bit lower in the case of a bullish engulfing, this being the reason why the engulfing is happening. Such a thing is not possible in the Forex market these days as execution is so accurate by the time one candle closes, those gaps are virtually impossible to form. By gaps, we’re talking about a significant and meaningful distance to be seen between the closing and the opening prices of two consecutive candles.

Bearish Engulfing

A bearish engulfing pattern is a bullish one, only that conditions should be considered on the reverse. This means that everything we stated on the bullish engulfing pattern is valid here as well, only the other way around we need a bullish trend, the fist candle is a green one and the second candle is a big red one that totally engulfs the previous one.
Explaining the Difference Between Engulfing and Piercing2
The image bellow shows how a bullish engulfing pattern is looking like on the Forex market, and the way to trade such a pattern is to buy at the close of the second candle, having a stop loss at the lows and a take profit that should respect the 1:3 risk reward ratio. This means that for every pip that is risked, there is three pips profit targeted.

The Piercing and Dark-Cloud Cover Patterns

It is worth mentioning right from the start that the piercing pattern can only be a bullish one. The equivalent of the piercing pattern is the dark-cloud cover that appears after a bullish trend.

The Piercing Pattern

The piercing pattern is almost like the engulfing one, with the difference that the second candle is not engulfing the previous one, but only goes into the territory of it. As a rule of thumb, the body of the second candle should retrace minimum fifty percent in the territory of the previous one.
Explaining the Difference Between Engulfing and Piercing3
Like it was the case with the engulfing pattern, trading the piercing or the dark-cloud cover should be the subject of going long (in the case of the piercing pattern) with a stop loss at the lows of the candle and a take profit that should respect the 1:3 risk reward ratio.

The Dark-Cloud Cover Pattern

Explaining the Difference Between Engulfing and Piercing2As opposed to the piercing pattern, the dark-cloud cover is a bearish reversal pattern, meaning it will form at the end of a bullish trend. This pattern will always have the second candle going into the territory of the previous one, with the second candle being a red bearish one and the first one a green, bullish one. The dark-cloud cover pattern is usually being followed by a stronger trend than in the case of a piercing pattern. This is coming from the fact that market is traveling faster to the downside than to the upside, with the panic factor influencing prices. This is especially true when it comes to trading the Forex market. With this article, we’re finishing up the part in our Forex Trading Academy dedicated to Japanese Candlestick Techniques. We’ve covered here the most important candlestick patterns that offer nice trading potential. However, there are many other things to consider with candlesticks, as multiple formations and groups of candles are still part of this wonderful trading theory. Nevertheless, the ones we treated here are the most representative ones, and, as reversal patterns, they allow a trader to be disciplined, offering a positive risk-reward ratio for a trade.

Was the information useful?
Engulfing and Piercing Explained
5 (100%) 6 votes